For a while now, the correspondence between a mathematical structure and the way nature behaves has puzzled and amazed me. In other words, Why is it that I can write down equations on a sheets of paper and predict something about a natural object?
Newtonian Mechanics had a certain mathematical structure and Maxwell's Electrodynamics had a certain mathematical structure, and these two structures couldn't co-exist. Just by trying make the equations co-variant, we were able to get great insights into the way nature worked. We could get testable predictions which we were ofcourse verified by experiment.
Quantum Mechanics brought in another mathematical structure which takes into account the relationship between the observer and the observed, and gives us the nature of a measurement.
There may be domains where experimental physics cannot yet reach. There may be some underlying physical phenomena which cannot yet be detected by experiments. To probe into those domains, as of now, we may only have mathematical tools at our disposal.
Here is a paragraph from a book on Quantum Mechanics by Bohm ( Ref 3) that I think is worth mentioning:
" Physicists believe that there is something in nature, or in each restricted domain of it, that may be "understood"; that there is a structure in nature. To "understand" means to bring this structure into congruence with some structure in our mind, with a structure of thought objects, with a structure that has been created by our minds. For physics, this structure of thought objects is a mathematical structure. So to understand part of physical nature means to map its structure on a mathematical structure. To obtain a physical theory, then, means to obtain a mathematical image of a physical system.
For the domains of quantum physics the mathematical structures are algebras of linear operators in linear spaces. The discovery of this, the fundamental properties of the algebra, and the other basic assumptions of quantum mechanics was a very difficult process. "
I just hope we have the capability to recognise the true underlying structure of nature( however naive this may sound).
P.s. The references are given in the column on the right.
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Mathematical structure of nature
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
0
comments
at
1:27 PM
Labels:
mathematical structure,
nature,
Raunaq
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Academy Lecture
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
0
comments
Indian Academy of Sciences
Bangalore
"Chandra: Gentleman, Scholar and Telescope"
Academy Public Lecture by
Professor Roger Blandford
Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology
Stanford
Date : Wednesday, 8th December 2010
Time: 6.00 p.m.
Venue: Faculty Hall, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore
Abstract: Professor Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, or "Chandra" as he was widely known, was a singular scientist and intellectual. Blessed with formidable mathematical ability and legendary powers of concentration, he was a scientific leader over an unequalled suite of the most challenging astrophysical disciplines. Although he may be most famous for his youthful discovery of a mass limit for white dwarfs and its famous corollary that black holes must exist, for which he was awarded the 1983 Nobel Prize, his lifetime contributions to mathematical physics, astrophysics and even the humanities, are even greater. The range and durability of his scholarship was memorialised in the naming of the finest imaging X-ray telescope ever launched. Vignettes from his life will be interspersed with a description of some of the amazing discoveries made by Chandra X-ray Observatory.
About the speaker: Roger Blandford is director of the Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology. He oversees research that seeks to answer some of our great cosmic questions: What powered the Big Bang? What are dark matter and dark energy? What is happening around black holes?. He is a Fellow of The Royal Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and a Member of the National Academy of Sciences.
All are welcome
Bangalore
"Chandra: Gentleman, Scholar and Telescope"
Academy Public Lecture by
Professor Roger Blandford
Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology
Stanford
Date : Wednesday, 8th December 2010
Time: 6.00 p.m.
Venue: Faculty Hall, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore
Abstract: Professor Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, or "Chandra" as he was widely known, was a singular scientist and intellectual. Blessed with formidable mathematical ability and legendary powers of concentration, he was a scientific leader over an unequalled suite of the most challenging astrophysical disciplines. Although he may be most famous for his youthful discovery of a mass limit for white dwarfs and its famous corollary that black holes must exist, for which he was awarded the 1983 Nobel Prize, his lifetime contributions to mathematical physics, astrophysics and even the humanities, are even greater. The range and durability of his scholarship was memorialised in the naming of the finest imaging X-ray telescope ever launched. Vignettes from his life will be interspersed with a description of some of the amazing discoveries made by Chandra X-ray Observatory.
About the speaker: Roger Blandford is director of the Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology. He oversees research that seeks to answer some of our great cosmic questions: What powered the Big Bang? What are dark matter and dark energy? What is happening around black holes?. He is a Fellow of The Royal Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and a Member of the National Academy of Sciences.
All are welcome
Coffee/tea will be served at 5.30 p.m.
Quantum Cryptography Lecture
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
0
comments
Centre for Quantum Information and Quantum Computing
Indian Institute of Science
Bangalore
Announces its lecture
By
Dr. Prabha Mandayam
Institute for Quantum Information
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, USA
Title:
" Uncertainty and Complementarity in Quantum Cryptography: Security in the Noisy Storage model"
On Wednesday the 8th December, 2010 at 4.00 pm
Venue: Lecture Hall - I, Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science.
Abstract
Historically, uncertainty relations have played an important role in our understanding of quantum mechanics. Recently, entropic uncertainty relations have gained prominence in the field of quantum information. In particular, they play a crucial role in analyzing the security of quantum cryptographic protocols such as quantum key-distribution and information locking. While optimal entropic uncertainty relations have been obtained for two measurements, not much is known in a general setting with more than two outcomes. We outline a novel construction of symmetric mutually unbiased bases (MUBs), using the 2n generators of the Clifford algebra in dimension d = 2^n. These bases satisfy the symmetry property that they are cyclically permuted under a unitary transformation. We prove a lower bound for entropic uncertainty relations for any set of MUBs and show that symmetry plays a central role in obtaining tight bounds. Finally, we describe a two-party protocol based on recent cryptographic models -- the "bounded-storage model" and the "noisy-storage model" -- whose security is directly related to a lower bound on the average entropy of complementary bases. While the security of most cryptographic systems in use today is based on the premise that certain computational problems are hard to solve for the adversary, these models are based on the physical assumption that no large-scale reliable quantum storage is available to the cheating party. Our protocol achieves security in the bounded-storage model even if the cheating party can store all but a constant fraction of the transmitted information, thus resolving an open question on the achievable physical limits of this model. In the general setting of the noisy-storage model, our protocol extends the range of storage devices for which security can be achieved.
Indian Institute of Science
Bangalore
Announces its lecture
By
Dr. Prabha Mandayam
Institute for Quantum Information
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, USA
Title:
" Uncertainty and Complementarity in Quantum Cryptography: Security in the Noisy Storage model"
On Wednesday the 8th December, 2010 at 4.00 pm
Venue: Lecture Hall - I, Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science.
Abstract
Historically, uncertainty relations have played an important role in our understanding of quantum mechanics. Recently, entropic uncertainty relations have gained prominence in the field of quantum information. In particular, they play a crucial role in analyzing the security of quantum cryptographic protocols such as quantum key-distribution and information locking. While optimal entropic uncertainty relations have been obtained for two measurements, not much is known in a general setting with more than two outcomes. We outline a novel construction of symmetric mutually unbiased bases (MUBs), using the 2n generators of the Clifford algebra in dimension d = 2^n. These bases satisfy the symmetry property that they are cyclically permuted under a unitary transformation. We prove a lower bound for entropic uncertainty relations for any set of MUBs and show that symmetry plays a central role in obtaining tight bounds. Finally, we describe a two-party protocol based on recent cryptographic models -- the "bounded-storage model" and the "noisy-storage model" -- whose security is directly related to a lower bound on the average entropy of complementary bases. While the security of most cryptographic systems in use today is based on the premise that certain computational problems are hard to solve for the adversary, these models are based on the physical assumption that no large-scale reliable quantum storage is available to the cheating party. Our protocol achieves security in the bounded-storage model even if the cheating party can store all but a constant fraction of the transmitted information, thus resolving an open question on the achievable physical limits of this model. In the general setting of the noisy-storage model, our protocol extends the range of storage devices for which security can be achieved.
All are Welcome
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
DO WE LEARN TO SEE ?
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
1 comments
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE
BANGALORE
Cordially invites you to a
CENTENARY LECTURE
by
Prof. Torsten Wiesel
Nobel Laureate
on
"DO WE LEARN TO SEE ?"
Date : 15th November 2010
Time : 4-00 p.m
Venue : Faculty Hall, Main Building
Prof. P. Balaram, Director
will preside
Prof. Torsten Wiesel
Nobel Laureate
on
"DO WE LEARN TO SEE ?"
Date : 15th November 2010
Time : 4-00 p.m
Venue : Faculty Hall, Main Building
Prof. P. Balaram, Director
will preside
Thursday, October 21, 2010
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
0
comments
I saw an interesting video on how groups were used by Garret in his model for a Theory of Everything. Here is the video. The group he used is an exotic Lie group commonly known as E8.
at
12:05 AM
Labels:
Group theory,
groups,
Raunaq
Monday, October 18, 2010
Group theory and Physics
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
4
comments
Most of us have group theory in our degree course. Some time ago, I was pretty critical about pure math and its abstract nature ( having nothing to do with reality). I treated them as just mental fantasies, some of which tends to have a structure that agrees with the way nature nature worked.
I went around telling people about some paradoxes in set theory and how Godel's theorem implies that any system based on precise axioms and set of rules is fundamentally flawed. One famous paradox is Russel's paradox.
I now realize that how I felt back then was wrong. I felt that way partly because I am not good at Math and partly because I my thinking was very naive. Which is not really a bad thing, I always learn from my naiveties.
I am now doing a project in Lie Groups under a professor in my college. And I visit a person named Dr. Aravinda from TIFR. He's helping me out with Topology and Differential Geometry. This is amazing because two years ago I didn't think I would find anyone working on these topics ( and also willing to guide me).
Anyway, I thought I'll put up something here that I found worth reading. This is the preface to one of the books that he suggested:
" As a graduate student in experimental physics, I found the study of group theory considered to be a useless "high-brow" luxury. Furthermore all attempts to follow a lecture course resulted in a losing battle with cosets, classes, invariant subgroups, normal divisors and assorted lemmas. It was impossible to learn all the definitions of new terms defined in one lecture and remember them until the next lecture. The result was complete chaos.
It was a great surprise to find later on that (1) Techniques based on group theory can be useful; (2) They can be learned and used without memorizing the large number of definitions and lemmas which frighten the uninitiated.
Angular momentum is presented in elementary quantum mechanics courses without a detailed analysis of the lie group of continuous rotations in three dimensions. The student learns about angular momentum multiplets and coupling angular momenta without realizing that these are irreducible representations of the rotation group.He also does not realize that the algebraic properties of other lie groups can be applied to physical problems in the same way as he used angular momentum algebra, with no need for classes, cosets etc. . . . . . . "
He then goes on to talk about further applications in creation and annihilation operators, and also talks about quasi spin etc..
The book is Lie groups for Pedestrians by Harry Lipkin.
Group theory is actually fun and beautiful ( a word I rarely use) , but again college takes the life out of it. I am actually lucky that this course is handled in my college by an expert in this topic, but even he is constrained because the college requires you to rush through all the theorems within one semester and one is not given enough time to understand the subtleties. But it is always best continue to reflect on it even after the course is done.
P.S: The weekend sessions have been going on. Everybody has just been too busy to put up the summary. We have had three sessions within a span of four days. Karthik made quite a lot of connections in classical mechanics during his class on friday. I conducted a test on saturday on whatever has been done, to judge the understanding so far. Today was Shruthi's session on QM, which was again taken up mostly by Karthik to make known previously unspoken things.
I went around telling people about some paradoxes in set theory and how Godel's theorem implies that any system based on precise axioms and set of rules is fundamentally flawed. One famous paradox is Russel's paradox.
I now realize that how I felt back then was wrong. I felt that way partly because I am not good at Math and partly because I my thinking was very naive. Which is not really a bad thing, I always learn from my naiveties.
I am now doing a project in Lie Groups under a professor in my college. And I visit a person named Dr. Aravinda from TIFR. He's helping me out with Topology and Differential Geometry. This is amazing because two years ago I didn't think I would find anyone working on these topics ( and also willing to guide me).
Anyway, I thought I'll put up something here that I found worth reading. This is the preface to one of the books that he suggested:
" As a graduate student in experimental physics, I found the study of group theory considered to be a useless "high-brow" luxury. Furthermore all attempts to follow a lecture course resulted in a losing battle with cosets, classes, invariant subgroups, normal divisors and assorted lemmas. It was impossible to learn all the definitions of new terms defined in one lecture and remember them until the next lecture. The result was complete chaos.
It was a great surprise to find later on that (1) Techniques based on group theory can be useful; (2) They can be learned and used without memorizing the large number of definitions and lemmas which frighten the uninitiated.
Angular momentum is presented in elementary quantum mechanics courses without a detailed analysis of the lie group of continuous rotations in three dimensions. The student learns about angular momentum multiplets and coupling angular momenta without realizing that these are irreducible representations of the rotation group.He also does not realize that the algebraic properties of other lie groups can be applied to physical problems in the same way as he used angular momentum algebra, with no need for classes, cosets etc. . . . . . . "
He then goes on to talk about further applications in creation and annihilation operators, and also talks about quasi spin etc..
The book is Lie groups for Pedestrians by Harry Lipkin.
Group theory is actually fun and beautiful ( a word I rarely use) , but again college takes the life out of it. I am actually lucky that this course is handled in my college by an expert in this topic, but even he is constrained because the college requires you to rush through all the theorems within one semester and one is not given enough time to understand the subtleties. But it is always best continue to reflect on it even after the course is done.
P.S: The weekend sessions have been going on. Everybody has just been too busy to put up the summary. We have had three sessions within a span of four days. Karthik made quite a lot of connections in classical mechanics during his class on friday. I conducted a test on saturday on whatever has been done, to judge the understanding so far. Today was Shruthi's session on QM, which was again taken up mostly by Karthik to make known previously unspoken things.
at
9:24 PM
Labels:
Group theory,
groups,
Raunaq
Saturday, October 16, 2010
CHANDRASEKHAR CENTENARY LECTURE
Posted by
Raunaq Ahmed
1 comments
Title: From white dwarfs to holography and quantum gravity
Date: 19th Oct, 4:00pm, CHEP Seminar Hall (IISC)
Abstract:
The talk aims to trace the influence of the Chandrasekhar limit
in understanding the physics of gravity. Here
is a summary of the salient points which will be covered
in the talk.
Around the time when Chandrasekhar was born ,
the white dwarf was regarded as a bete noir by astronomers. During
1930-35 , Chandrasekhar proved that massive stars which have
run out their fuel , can not rest in peace as white dwarfs if their mass
exceeds 1.44 times the mass of the Sun , because gravitation will
overwhelm all other forces and they must collapse.
Recalling later developments, in 1982 during the Eddington centenary
lecture Chandrasekhar said " the existence for a limiting mass is
inextricably woven into the present fabric of astronomical tapestry with
its complex designs of stellar evolution , nuclear burning in the
high - density cores of certain stars and gravitational collapse
leading to supernova phenomenon and the formation of neutron stars of
nearly the same mass and of black holes. " .
In the nineteen thirties famous but older physicists disliked the idea
of ultimate collapse and disapproved of singularities of the equations of
physics. Along with the issue of stellar collapse there was also the
parallel problem regarding cosmological singularities present in
models of the Universe . Are singularities rigorous results of equations
of physics or the work of maladroit theorist ? The seminal work of
Raychaudhuri in the fifties , paved the way for Penrose Hawking and
Geroch , to prove a decade later
-1) the inevitability for collapse into black hole by a massive star
on the one hand
2) strengthened the basis of big bang cosmology on the other . It is
consistent with astronomical data to assume that our Universe
began with a singularity .
Today thousands of white dwarfs with mass below Chandrasekhar limit are
known with their structure and properties well understood . They are an
important standard in astronomy. Many stellar mass black holes are known
today.
Classical black holes absorb everything and pose a problem for the second
law of thermodynamics . Hawking's discovery that in quantum theory ,
black holes must radiate resolves this but brings in fresh issues in its
wake , challenging our understanding of interface
between the inside and outside of a black hole .
Speaker: J. Pasupathy.
Affiliation: CHEP
I think we should all attend this lecture. Seems mouthwatering. Ciao
Date: 19th Oct, 4:00pm, CHEP Seminar Hall (IISC)
Abstract:
The talk aims to trace the influence of the Chandrasekhar limit
in understanding the physics of gravity. Here
is a summary of the salient points which will be covered
in the talk.
Around the time when Chandrasekhar was born ,
the white dwarf was regarded as a bete noir by astronomers. During
1930-35 , Chandrasekhar proved that massive stars which have
run out their fuel , can not rest in peace as white dwarfs if their mass
exceeds 1.44 times the mass of the Sun , because gravitation will
overwhelm all other forces and they must collapse.
Recalling later developments, in 1982 during the Eddington centenary
lecture Chandrasekhar said " the existence for a limiting mass is
inextricably woven into the present fabric of astronomical tapestry with
its complex designs of stellar evolution , nuclear burning in the
high - density cores of certain stars and gravitational collapse
leading to supernova phenomenon and the formation of neutron stars of
nearly the same mass and of black holes. " .
In the nineteen thirties famous but older physicists disliked the idea
of ultimate collapse and disapproved of singularities of the equations of
physics. Along with the issue of stellar collapse there was also the
parallel problem regarding cosmological singularities present in
models of the Universe . Are singularities rigorous results of equations
of physics or the work of maladroit theorist ? The seminal work of
Raychaudhuri in the fifties , paved the way for Penrose Hawking and
Geroch , to prove a decade later
-1) the inevitability for collapse into black hole by a massive star
on the one hand
2) strengthened the basis of big bang cosmology on the other . It is
consistent with astronomical data to assume that our Universe
began with a singularity .
Today thousands of white dwarfs with mass below Chandrasekhar limit are
known with their structure and properties well understood . They are an
important standard in astronomy. Many stellar mass black holes are known
today.
Classical black holes absorb everything and pose a problem for the second
law of thermodynamics . Hawking's discovery that in quantum theory ,
black holes must radiate resolves this but brings in fresh issues in its
wake , challenging our understanding of interface
between the inside and outside of a black hole .
Speaker: J. Pasupathy.
Affiliation: CHEP
I think we should all attend this lecture. Seems mouthwatering. Ciao
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)